What’s up with Canada?

  • Hamas just invaded Israel and now Gaza is under siege. And somehow, it’s all Justin Trudeau’s fault.

    Just kidding, nobody’s suggesting that… yet. For now, Canadians seem to understand that Canada is small and peace in the Middle East is complex, and that all the prime minister can really offer at a time like this is moral clarity where it’s desperately needed.

    So here’s what Trudeau had to say: “The glorification of death and violence and terror has no place anywhere, including especially here in Canada. Hamas … aren’t … freedom fighters, they are terrorists. And no one in Canada should be supporting them, much less celebrating them.”

    Trudeau is exactly right. I support a free Palestine. But the first step toward liberation is freedom from Hamas – a terrorist organization that has used machine guns to impose religious laws from the Middle Ages on Gaza’s 2 million residents for 17 years without an election.

    And to be completely clear: Israel, for all its faults, is at war with Hamas, not Palestine. The fact that Israel is preventing electricity and aid from reaching Gaza is horrible, and perhaps even a war crime. But it is in response to war crimes committed by Hamas, who genuinely give zero fucks about human life.

    So far, Canada’s other major political parties share this reality-based evaluation of the situation. NDP leader Jagmeet Singh released a statement saying that he is “horrified” by the “terrorist attacks by Hamas on thousands of innocent Israeli civilians.”

    And here’s what Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre had to say: “Hamas is not a militant organization; it is not an activist organization; it is surely not a government; it is a sadistic, demonic, genocidal, terrorist death-cult – and it must be defeated and destroyed.”

    So our major parties can agree on something. The supporters of our major parties, on the other hand, cannot. Underneath the pro-Israel social media posts from Liberal, NDP and Conservative politicians you’ll find comment after after comment to the effect of: “you just lost my vote” or “you just lost half your votes.” I know politicians and their staff are thick-skinned – but that can’t be easy to take in at a time like this.

    The reason Trudeau, Singh and Poilievre can agree about Hamas, if nothing else, is because Hamas really are terrorists … and, if you have the stomach to read the more detailed reports, verifiable monsters as well. But facts don’t matter for many people when emotions run high — and emotions definitely run high when religion is involved.

    The conflict between Israel and Palestine is popularly depicted as a classic David vs Goliath story – with the Jews very ironically playing role of Goliath: Never mind that there’s only 16 million Jews and one Jewish-majority country in the world compared to 2.3 billion Muslims and 50 Muslim-controlled countries; and never mind that the Palestine movement is very much bankrolled by the international community.

    So will one of Canada’s major political parties choose to forgo reason, change course and court the very popular, if completely misguided, anti-Israel vote? Or will a fringe wing or fringe party rise up to fill this void? And how will this war, should it be as big and drag on for as long as some are suggesting, affect domestic Canadian politics?

    My guess, for what it’s worth, is that if any major Canadian political party goes for the anti-Israel vote, it won’t be the Liberals or the Conservatives. It will be the NDP – because of good-old, old-fashioned, left-wing antisemitism. I take no pleasure in saying that.

    And my hope, for what it’s worth, is for a quick end to the violence… followed by a complete collective rejection of religion. And yes, I realize that most people claim the Israel-Palestine conflict isn’t really about religion; that it’s really about global geopolitics, or oil, or whatever.

    But Hamas literally named this depraved attack on Israel after an ancient church that they’re super pissed is on Israeli land. So no matter what people say, I’m pretty sure religion has something to do with it.

    What Justin Trudeau can do about Gaza

    was published

    Subscribe

  • This will surprise nobody: If an election were held today, Pierre Poilievre would clobber Justin Trudeau. According to the latest poll, 38% of Canadians now support the Conservatives and only 26% support the Liberals.

    But this may surprise you: If only Millennials could vote, the clobbering would be worse. Forty percent of Millennials now say they’d vote for Poilievre’s Conservatives and just 21% say they’d vote for Trudeau’s Liberals – putting them in third behind Jagmeet Singh’s NDP.

    OK, maybe that isn’t actually surprising: Millennials have endured an unrelenting economic grind since entering the workforce in the fallout of the financial crisis, and they’ve undeniably borne the brunt of Canada’s affordability crisis. Plus Millennials are old and grumpy now.

    But still: This is definitely new. As recently as February 2022, before Poilievre became party leader, only 24% of young Canadians supported the Conservatives and 32% supported the Liberals. But by July 2023, in the middle of Poilievre’s “Canada is broken” summer tour, Conservative support among young Canadians had soared to 31% while Liberal support had sunken to 29%.

    So how did Poilievre overtake Trudeau and double Millennial support for the Conservative party in under two years? By relentlessly blaming Trudeau for something that genuinely is broken: Housing.

    Historically, owning a home in Canada cost an average of 41% of household income. But now Canadians are spending an average of 60% of their incomes on their homes. In Toronto, it’s up to 80%. Who can afford that?

    The issue is particularly acute for newer homeowners who took on huge, long-term, variable-rate mortgages when interest rates were at historical lows – and who’ve since seen their monthly payments increase by an average of 49% in 2023. Who can afford that?

    And the situation is no better for renters. The average rent in Canada is up nearly 10% from 2022 and has been rising by around $100 per month since May. In August, the average asking rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Toronto was more than $3,400. Who can afford that?

    Fewer and fewer people, it turns out: A survey published this week found that a staggering 63% of Canadians are now living pay cheque to pay cheque – including 30% who are spending their savings or going into debt just to cover their monthly expenses.

    This is an extremely serious problem. Things are looking genuinely grim for a lot of Canadians right now. And a lot of people are understandably angry about it. And it is this despair-fueled rage that Poilievre has become such an effective spokesperson for.

    It’s worth noting that Poilievre isn’t offering any serious solutions. He’d cancel the carbon tax, which would make gas a bit less expensive; he’d defund the CBC, which would make Canada a lot less informed; and he’d cut TBD government waste, which would mean public sector layoffs and social service cuts.

    That won’t fix anything – let alone the housing crisis. But Poilievre isn’t interested in fixing Canada. He’s just trying to convince Canadians that Trudeau broke it. And he’s doing a great job.

    Millennials are Conservative now

    was published

    Subscribe

  • I’ll admit my initial reaction to learning that the Canadian government gave two standing ovations to a 98-year-old who literally fought for the Nazis was to feel sorry for the guy responsible: Anthony Rota.

    Before resigning earlier this week, Rota served admirably as speaker of the House of Commons. He was remarkably nonpartisan, despite having to deal with an unrelentingly unprofessional Conservative party. And he obviously isn’t a Nazi, or Russian propagandist, or anything like that.

    Plus, as somebody who can make them from time to time, my general position is this: People shouldn’t be defined by their mistakes, unless their mistakes define them.

    But this sense of compassion has since given way to new feelings: contempt and curiosity.

    First: contempt. Everybody makes mistakes, sure; but this mistake is absolutely massive. It’s one thing to take a very old man at his word when he tells you about his time in the war; it’s another to not google his name before shouting him out in front of Volodymyr Zelenskyy.

    Rota meant well, of course. But he may as well have accidentally fired a missile by sitting on the launch button, considering all the damage he has done to the Liberals. How could he and his staff be so careless when this situation so obviously called for so much care?

    Which brings us to my second delayed reaction: curiosity. Just how bad is this going to turn out for Trudeau? Because – while I know it seems inconceivable now – our deeply unpopular prime minister was just on the cusp of making a comeback.

    Trudeau had finally taken steps to fix Canada’s housing crisis – both by waiving the GST for new rental construction and by beginning to talk openly about the fact that home prices can’t keep going up (sorry, homeowners).

    Whatever you think of him, Trudeau’s better-late-than-never plan is the same or better than the one put forward by Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre.

    And Trudeau had just taken a stand against food price inflation that could be accurately described as “gangsta.” He summoned the leaders of Canada’s biggest grocery chains to Ottawa, berated them, then ordered them to stabilize prices by Thanksgiving “or I will.”

    Whatever you think of him, that’s some cold-blooded shit to say to Galen Weston — and as the kids say, I’m here for it.

    Plus Trudeau had just let Indian prime minister Narendra Modi know that he’s not somebody to fuck with after Modi tried to stonewall an investigation linking the Indian government to the murder of a Canadian Sikh in B.C in June.

    Whatever you think of him, that’s a power move to take against a superpower — and it’s forcing our allies to publicly admit what they privately know about India’s interference in diaspora communities.

    And then of course there was the Zelenskyy visit itself… prior to the Nazi thing, I mean. The Ukrainian president spent two days thanking Canadians — but Trudeau in particular — for steadfastly supporting Ukraine and courageously condemning Russia.

    So things really were starting to look up for the prime minister. But then he was dealt this fresh disaster. And all that really matters now is: How will Trudeau respond — and how will we?

    Canada accidentally honours a Nazi

    was published

    Subscribe

Canadian politics but interesting.

What’s up with Cody Gault?

Contact

Privacy